Best of the Midwest

Q2 Product Investment Request

Making the Best of the Midwest work harder: automation, experience and speed.

Prepared for

Chief Revenue Officer & Chief Technology Officer

Date

October 2026

01 — Executive summary

Our contests drive the business. The site is holding them back.

bestofthemidwest.com runs on manual contest handoffs, multiple URLs per contest, landing pages that can take over a minute to load, and a homepage that doesn't look like the travel destination we are.

We are requesting approval and engineering capacity for 16 initiatives across three pillars, all requested for Q2.

Estimated annual revenue impact

$76K–$179K

Modeled on current contest revenue of $875K, already up 14% year over year.

Plus estimated labor savings

$14K–$23K

290–490 staff hours a year freed from manual contest work.

01

Smarter Contests

Automation + contest navigation

Contests are our biggest traffic and revenue engine. Automating phase changes and making results easier to browse removes manual work and keeps voters engaged longer.

5 initiatives

02

Content & Discovery

Look and feel like a travel destination

Competitors win on visual storytelling. Video, editorial signals and richer navigation turn one-time contest voters into repeat readers.

10 initiatives

03

Performance & Operations

The foundation everything else depends on

Formalizing the data team process reduces manual work, speeds up contest operations and protects revenue we already earn.

1 initiatives

02 — The initiatives

What we're asking for, and why

Smarter Contests

Automation + contest navigation
#1
Q2 request

Automated, phase-aware contest CTAs

What
Prominent calls to action in the Browse contest list that change automatically with the contest phase (Nominate, Vote, See Winners). Convert the existing custom module into a reusable automated Contest CTA module.
Why it matters
Today CTAs are static or updated by hand, so users often see the wrong action for the phase and staff spend time swapping modules.
Expected impact
Higher click-through into active contests; fewer manual updates per contest cycle.
Est. annual revenue$7K–$14K / yr
Est. savings · 80–160 staff hrs/yr$4K–$7K / yr
#2
Q2 request

One contest page, one URL

What
Consolidate nomination, voting and winners into a single page and URL that transitions between phases automatically behind the scenes.
Why it matters
Users are sent to different pages throughout a contest, so bookmarks and shared links break. Sales and marketing must promote multiple URLs.
Expected impact
One URL to promote, stronger SEO equity on a single page, better return visits across phases.
Est. annual revenue$13K–$26K / yr
Est. savings · 120–240 staff hrs/yr$5K–$11K / yr
#3
Q2 request

Scrollable category sidebar (desktop results)

What
A scrollable list of categories in the sidebar of the contest results page on desktop.
Why it matters
Users must open the filterable search to jump between categories, adding friction and ending sessions early.
Expected impact
More categories viewed per session, more ad impressions per visit.
Est. annual revenue$2K–$4K / yr
#4
Q2 request

Current category shown in the search bar

What
Display the category the user is viewing inside the search bar on the results page.
Why it matters
Users lose track of where they are in large contests, which makes the page feel confusing.
Expected impact
Clearer wayfinding and lower bounce on results pages.
Est. annual revenue$987–$2K / yr
#5
Q2 request

Group name as a dropdown

What
Turn the group name on the results page into a dropdown to switch groups in place.
Why it matters
Switching groups currently requires going back to the main page or using search.
Expected impact
Faster browsing across groups, more pageviews per session.
Est. annual revenue$987–$3K / yr

Content & Discovery

Look and feel like a travel destination
#6
Q2 request

Staff Pick badge

What
A badge for staff-pick stories, similar to Breaking News or Subscribers Only labels on news sites.
Why it matters
We have no way to signal editorial authority, which is a key trust cue for travel audiences.
Expected impact
Higher story click-through; a Staff Pick feature that can be bundled with Enhanced Business Listings ($150/mo).
Est. annual revenue$9K–$18K / yr
#7
Q2 request

Homepage video hub

What
A native video scroller on the homepage so video has a home beyond social embeds inside stories.
Why it matters
Video is the highest-engagement format in travel, and we currently have nowhere to showcase it.
Expected impact
Longer time on site and a new premium video ad / sponsorship inventory.
Est. annual revenue$9K–$22K / yr
#8
Q2 request

Header navigation dropdowns

What
Enable dropdowns in the top navigation for location-based browsing and timely topics with multiple article links.
Why it matters
Our navigation lags the industry standard, making it hard to explore by state or season.
Expected impact
Location menus drive more eyeballs to our state and city pages, where Enhanced Business Listings ($150/mo) appear, making those listings more visible and easier to sell. Also improves retention and pages per session.
Est. annual revenue$5K–$14K / yr
#9
Q2 request

Homepage redesign

What
A more visual, travel-style homepage with splashy photography, inspired by Midwest Living and the North Dakota, Minnesota and South Dakota tourism sites.
Why it matters
Our homepage doesn't look like a travel destination, so we lose on first impressions and are missing out on the splashy features that other travel destination sites have.
Expected impact
Stronger brand perception, higher homepage engagement, premium large leaderboard inventory ($20 CPM) on a high-visibility homepage.
Est. annual revenue$4K–$13K / yr
#10
Q2 request

Location name in SEO titles and descriptions

What
Add the location name to the SEO page title and meta description of the Contest Results page and every Contest Category page.
Why it matters
Contest and category pages currently leave the location out of page titles and descriptions, so they are hard to find in local searches.
Expected impact
Easier for people to find contests and categories for their area in organic search, bringing more free traffic to contest pages.
Est. annual revenue$2K–$4K / yr
#11
Q2 request

State field for locations

What
Add a state field to each location.
Why it matters
The location dropdown is long and unorganized, and search engines get no clear regional context.
Expected impact
Better UX: a cleaner, organized location dropdown. Stronger SEO: clearer regional context for search engines and users.
Est. annual revenue$2K–$5K / yr
#12
Q2 request

Breadcrumbs on contest and location pages

What
Add breadcrumbs to contest and location pages to show where each page sits in the site.
Why it matters
Users have no easy way to move between the layers of contest and location pages, and search engines get a flatter site structure.
Expected impact
Better UX: easier movement between contest and location layers. Stronger SEO: improved site architecture and crawlability.
Est. annual revenue$987–$3K / yr
#13
Q2 request

Section pages and content labels

What
Organize content into state and topical section pages (food, travel, culture, stays, experiences) with category labels above headlines.
Why it matters
Stories are hard to scan and there is no dedicated home for a state or topic.
Expected impact
Faster scanning: labels help users spot topics and locations. Easier discovery: section pages invite exploring a state or interest, and create new sponsorable sections.
Est. annual revenue$4K–$9K / yr
#14
Q2 request

Custom template for Best-Of listicles

What
A dedicated article template for category winners that pairs a numbered list with an interactive map (similar to Eater.com), with business details (address, website, phone, photos) filled in by an automated module.
Why it matters
Best-Of articles are built by hand with inconsistent formatting, so they feel less premium and take staff time.
Expected impact
Enhanced UX: users can explore winners visually on a map. Consistent formatting: premium, easy-to-scan lists that make winner packages more valuable to advertisers.
Est. annual revenue$2K–$5K / yr
#15
Q2 request

Searchable business directory

What
A Yelp-style, site-wide directory that gathers every business profile in one place, with filters by state, city, category, total award count, contest year and recency, plus category pages such as "Top Breweries" or "Best Coffee".
Why it matters
Today users can only find businesses through yearly contest pages or the AI Answers module, so past contest data sits buried in archives.
Expected impact
Enhanced discovery with a clean, filterable list. Year-round utility for our historical contest data. Category pages we can link straight from location pages, creating a natural home for Enhanced Business Listings.
Est. annual revenue$14K–$36K / yr

Performance & Operations

The foundation everything else depends on
#16
Q2 request

Data team process standardization

What
Four data team updates, applied to every contest site. All four items are owned by the Advertising team.
Why it matters
Each site is set up slightly differently, so the data team repeats manual cleanup, and late entrant fixes can change voting outcomes.
Expected impact
About 4.5 staff hours saved per site, cleaner data and fewer voting disputes.
  • Standardized categories · avg 15 min per site
    Standardize the category list and response formatting.
  • Standardized number of published winners · avg 2 hrs per site
    List a set number of winners and runners-up (e.g. 3) across the board.
  • More extensive pre-voting review · avg 2 hrs per site
    Review entrant name consolidation and eligibility before voting, since errors caught late can change the outcome.
  • Standardized group names · avg 15 min per site
    Use the same group names across every site.
Est. annual revenueCost savings
Est. savings · 90 staff hrs/yr$5K / yr

03 — Revenue model

Estimated annual revenue by initiative

#InitiativeLiftLowHigh
1Automated, phase-aware contest CTAs2.0–4.0% of nomination + voting$7K$14K
2One contest page, one URL1.5–3.0% of contest revenue$13K$26K
3Scrollable category sidebar (desktop results)1.0–2.0% of voting revenue$2K$4K
4Current category shown in the search bar0.5–1.0% of voting revenue$987$2K
5Group name as a dropdown0.5–1.5% of voting revenue$987$3K
6Staff Pick badge5–10 new enhanced listings$9K$18K
7Homepage video hub1.0–2.5% of contest revenue$9K$22K
8Header navigation dropdowns3–8 new enhanced listings$5K$14K
9Homepage redesign1.0–3.0% of winners revenue$4K$13K
10Location name in SEO titles and descriptions1.0–2.0% of voting revenue$2K$4K
11State field for locations1–3 new enhanced listings$2K$5K
12Breadcrumbs on contest and location pages0.5–1.5% of voting revenue$987$3K
13Section pages and content labels2–5 new enhanced listings$4K$9K
14Custom template for Best-Of listicles2.0–5.0% of post-win revenue$2K$5K
15Searchable business directory8–20 new enhanced listings$14K$36K
16Data team process standardizationCost savings only$0$0
Total estimated impact$76K$179K

04 — The ask

Let's build the next chapter together

Best of the Midwest is already growing, and our readers, voters and advertisers have shown us how much they love celebrating the places that make this region special. We're asking you to invest in these Q2 improvements so the product can keep up with that momentum. Automating our contests will free our team from manual handoffs and let us spend that time on great content. A faster, easier and more beautiful site will give our audience the experience they deserve, and keep them coming back. Together these changes open new revenue from video, sponsorships and premium placements, while protecting the revenue we already earn. We can turn a product people already love into the go-to destination for the Midwest, and put Best of the Midwest firmly on the road to its next stage of growth.

Best of the Midwest

Thank you.